With the Academy Awards already here, I thought I’d give a quick rundown of my thoughts about who will and who should win. Although I have managed to miss out on a few nominated films, my “will win” picks are partly based on what I’ve heard and read. Here are some of the categories in which I’ve seen all or most of the nominees…
(* means I’ve seen the nominee)
Best Actor
Philip Seymour Hoffman* (Capote) Will Win, Should Win
Terrence Howard* (Huste & Flow)
Heath Ledger* (Brokeback Mountain)
Joaquin Pheonix* (Walk the Line)
David Strathairn* (Good Night, and Good Luck.)
I think every actor here gives a strong performance and I really wish they could all win, but Hoffman is just so chillingly effective and encapsulates the odd and peculiar behavior of Truman Capote.
Best Supporting Actor
George Clooney* (Syriana) Will Win
Matt Dillon* (Crash) Should Win
Paul Giamatti* (Cinderella Man)
Jake Gyllenhaal* (Brokeback Mountain)
William Hurt* (A History of Violence)
It would be so cool to see the usual sleazebag and comedic driven Matt Dillon win this award. And although Paul Giamatti is so exciting and fun, and Jake Gyllenhaal gives the performance of his career thus far, I think that Clooney’s gritty and courageous performance will take the statuette.
Best Actress
Judi Dench (Mrs. Henderson Presents)
Felicity Huffman (Transamerica)
Keira Knightley* (Pride & Prejudice)
Charlize Theron* (North Country) Should Win
Reese Witherspoon* (Walk the Line) Will Win
If I had seen Transamerica I just might have voted for Huffman, but I think that Charlize Theron gives the most natural and heart-wrenching performance. Reese Witherspoon, however, with the most critical acclaim, gives the biggest stretch as being a feisty and charismatic brunette while doing her very own vocals as June Carter.
Best Supporting Actress
Amy Adams* (Junebug)
Catherine Keener* (Capote)
Frances McDormand* (North Country)
Rachel Weisz* (The Constant Gardener) Will Win, Should Win
Michelle Williams* (Brokeback Mountain)
I think Adams or Williams could be an upset here as they give such convincing performances, but it is Rachel Weisz who completely mesmerized me with her powerful and persevering character in my favorite film of 2005 (see my Top Ten blog).
Best Art Direction
Good Night, and Good Luck.*
Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire*
King Kong*
Memoirs of a Geisha* Will Win, Should Win
Pride & Prejudice*
Memoirs of a Geisha is simply a visual beauty and captures the Japanese culture through its rich colors and breathtaking sets and locations.
Best Cinematography
Batman Begins*
Brokeback Mountatin*
Good Night, and Good Luck.* Should Win
Memoirs of a Geisha* Will Win
The New World
Although I love Memoirs of a Geisha and think it will win, I think Good Night, and Good Luck uses the camera very strategically to every advantage.
Best Costume Design
Charlie and the Chocolate Factory*
Memoirs of a Geisha* Will Win, Should Win
Mrs. Henderson Presents
Pride & Prejudice*
Walk the Line*
Oscar winner Colleen Atwood (Chicago) designed for Memoirs and totally deserves it.
Best Editing
Cinderella Man*
The Constant Gardener* Should Win
Crash* Will Win
Munich*
Walk the Line*
Crash will probably take it with its intertwining storylines, but I can’t help but love the fast-paced and raw editing that goes back and forth in The Constant Gardener.
Best Makeup
The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe* Will Win, Should Win
Cinderella Man*
Memoirs of a Geisha*
Chronicles is simply the best of these with intricate and innovative ways to bring fantasy creatures to life.
Best Original Score
Brokeback Mountain* (Gustavo Santaolalla)
The Constant Gardener* (Alberto Iglesias)
Memoirs of a Geisha* (John Williams) Will Win, Should Win
Munich* (John Williams)
Pride & Prejudice* (Dario Marianelli)
Even though I absolutely love the romantic score of Pride & Prejudice, I’m a sucker for anything done by John Williams and his enchanting oriental score adds to his diversity of compositions.
Best Sound Editing
King Kong* Will Win, Should Win
Memoirs of a Geisha*
War of the Worlds
With stampedes of dinosaurs, man-eating bugs, and a giant roaring ape, King Kong has such a broad range of sounds that conquers Memoirs and War of the Worlds, even though I didn’t see the latter (thanks to the presence of Tom Cruise).
Best Sound Mixing
The Chronicles of Narnia*
King Kong* Should Win
Memoirs of a Geisha*
Walk the Line* Will Win
War of the Worlds
Walk the Line will take it since Ray took it last year.
Best Visual Effects
The Chronicles of Narnia*
King Kong* Will Win, Should Win
War of the Worlds
Unbelievably real. End of story.
Best Adapted Screenplay
Brokeback Mountain* Will Win, Should Win
Capote*
The Constant Gardener*
A History of Violence*
Munich*
Having not read the original works in which these films were adapted from, I’m going with what has previously won.
Best Original Screenplay
Crash* Will Win, Should Win
Good Night, and Good Luck.*
Match Point*
Syriana*
I really like the language and direction of Good Night, and Good Luck, but Crash captures such diverse stories in a brave and risky film.
Best Director
Ang Lee* (Brokeback Mountain) Will Win, Should Win
Bennet Miller* (Capote)
Paul Haggis* (Crash)
George Clooney* (Good Night, and Good Luck.)
Steven Spielberg* (Munich)
Because I had to give at least something else to Brokeback Mountain. And besides, under the circumstances, I think Ang Lee was very courageous to take on this film and he wonderfully guides four breakout performances.
Best Picture
Brokeback Mountain* Will Win, Should Win
Capote*
Crash*
Good Night, and Good Luck.*
Munich*
I have to say that all of these films have something powerful to say, but Brokeback Mountain’s issues are more groundbreaking and there is something new there that we haven’t seen in theaters. A film that produces controversy and conversation while simultaneously telling a beautiful and tragic love story deserves to win this honor.
Don't forget to watch the Academy Awards this Sunday on ABC at 8et/5pt! Let's just hope they don't start giving out awards in the audience again like last year. Happy Oscar Watching!